Браковете на Мухаммад: противоречие с Корана
Въведение
Пророкът Мухаммад е имал толкова много жени, че учените не са единодушни помежду си относно техния брой. Със сигурност е известно, че Мухаммад е имал поне минимум девет съпруги наведнъж непосредствено преди смъртта си. По този начин Мухаммад е нарушил заповедта на Корана, който позволява на мъжете да имат само четири съпруги наведнъж.
Muslim Claim
The following verse restricts the total number of wives to four:
Muslims cite the following verse of the Qur'an to imply that Muhammad was exempt from this restriction:
Analysis
Meaning of the Verse
No where in the above verse is it mentioned that Muhammad could have more than four wives. If one reads the verse, it is obvious that the only privilege in this case is that Muhammad could have any woman who willingly offered herself i.e. without Mahr (dowry),[1] that seems to be the possible reason for this translation:
Hadith Evidence
The hadiths related to this verse do not make any mention of Muhammad receiving the privilege of having more than four wives. They only relate to women offering themselves to Muhammad, thereby supporting the previous translation:
Sahih Bukhari
Sahih Muslim
Conclusion
The Qur'anic text does not support the idea that Prophet Muhammad was given an exemption concerning the number of women one could marry. When we look at the hadiths we find that it is referring to women who willingly offered themselves to him without a Mahr.
Thus it is clear that Muhammad violated the Qur'an by marrying more than four wives at a time. If Muhammad was to be an example for all male Muslims in the future, he should have obeyed Allah's orders in the Qur'an.
See Also
- Muhammad and the Violation of the Qur'an
- Polygamy - Страница, която води до други статии, свързани с Polygamy
References
- ↑ The Message of the Quran translated and explained by Muhammad Asad [The Book Foundation, England 2003], fn. 60, p. 728
- ↑ Rashid Kalifha's 033:050