УикиИслям

Отговори на защитниците: Мухаммад и Аиша: Разлика между версии

Страница Беседа

Отговори на защитниците: Мухаммад и Аиша (преглед на кода)

Версия от 14:57, 20 март 2018

175 байта добавени ,  20 март 2018
→‎При горещ климат менструацията започва по-рано отколкото при студен, следователно момичетата в Арабия са съзрявали още на 9 години
[проверена версия][проверена версия]
Ред 72: Ред 72:
  ''East Germany 14.0* Morabia et al. <BR>Ghana 13.98 Adadevoh et <BR>Greece 12.0 Pentzos-Daponte Peters (1984) <BR>Guatemala 13.75 Khan et al. (1995) <BR>Haiti 15.37 Barnes-Josiah <BR>Hungary 12.9 Dober and Kiralyfalvi <BR>Iceland 13.06 Macgusson <BR>India (Punjab) 14.31 Singh and Ahuja <BR>Indonesia 13.0 Samsudin (1990) <BR>Ireland 13.52 Hoey et al. (1986) <BR>Israel 13.29 Belmaker (1982) <BR>Italia 12.2 Zoppi (1992) <BR>Jamaica 13.1 Jamaica National (1988) <BR>Japan 12.5 Nakamura et <BR>Kenya 14.4 Rogo et al. (1987) <BR>Malaysia 14.2 Wilson (1985)<BR>Mexico 12.4 Garcia-Baltazar <BR>Morocco 13.75* Loukid et al. <BR>Nepal (high altitude) 16.2* Beall (1983) <BR>New-Zealand 12.9 St George et <BR>Nicaragua 14.0 Guido et al. <BR>Nigeria 15.0* Morabia et al. <BR>Norway 13.2* Nafstad et al. <BR>Papua New Guinea 15.8 Groos and Smith <BR>Peru 13.23 Soto-Caceres Servigon <BR>Philippines 13.6 Zablan (1988) <BR>Poland 13.06 Laska-Mierzejewska et al. (1982) — — <BR>Romania 13.47 Stukovsky et al. (1967) — — <BR>Russia 13.0 Iampol’skaia (1997) 49.0 Balan (1995) <BR>Sardinia 12.78* Floris et al. (1987) — — <BR>Senegal 16.1 Simondon et al. (1997) — — <BR>Somalia 14.78 Gallo (1975) — — <BR>South Africa (black women) — — 49.2 Walker et al. (1984) <BR>Southern Korea 13.9 Kim et al. (1986) — — <BR>Spain 12.31 de la Puente et al. (1997) — — <BR>Sri Lanka 13.5 Balasuriya and Fernando (1983) — — <BR>Sudan 13.75 Attallah et al. (1983) — — <BR>Sweden 13.09 Furu (1976) 50.9* Hagstad (1988) <BR>Switzerland 13.0 Morabia et al. (1996) 50.0 Morabia et al. (1996) <BR>Tahiti 12.75* Ducros and Ducros (1987) — — <BR>Taiwan 13.6 Chow et al. (1997) 49.5 Chow et al. (1997) <BR>Tanzania 15.21 Hautvast (1971) — — <BR>Thailand 12.3 Piya-Anant et al. (1997) 50.3 Tungphaisal et al. (1991) <BR>Turkey 13.28 Vicdan et al. (1996) 47.8 Carda et al. (1998) <BR>United Arab Emirates — — 47.3 Rizk et al. (1998) <BR>USA 12.8 Malina and Bouchard (1991) 51.3* Kato et al. (1998) <BR>Venezuela 12.68* Farid-Coupal et al. (1981) — — <BR>Yemen 14.4 Yemen Arab Republic Fertility Survey (1979) — — <BR>Zambia 13.7 Katzarski et al. (1980) — — <BR>Zimbabwe 13.5 Mbizvo et al. (1995) — —''"</ref><ref>Also see [http://wikiislam.net/wiki/File:Mean_ages_of_menarche_around_the_world.jpg this] table on the mean ages of menarche around the world (Reference: "[{{Reference archive|1=http://www.mum.org/menarage.htm|2=2013-01-11}} Average age at menarche in various cultures]," The Museum of Menarche (mum.org), accessed January 12, 2013).</ref> В много случаи истината е точно обратната на това, което апологетите казват. Например средната възраст при първа менструация за Дания, Финландия и Великобритания е съответно 13.0, 13.2 и 13.3 години. За сравнение средната възраст при първа менструация за Сенегал, Танзания и Йемен е съответно 16.1, 15.21 и 14.4 години.<ref name="HuBioVol73"></ref>
  ''East Germany 14.0* Morabia et al. <BR>Ghana 13.98 Adadevoh et <BR>Greece 12.0 Pentzos-Daponte Peters (1984) <BR>Guatemala 13.75 Khan et al. (1995) <BR>Haiti 15.37 Barnes-Josiah <BR>Hungary 12.9 Dober and Kiralyfalvi <BR>Iceland 13.06 Macgusson <BR>India (Punjab) 14.31 Singh and Ahuja <BR>Indonesia 13.0 Samsudin (1990) <BR>Ireland 13.52 Hoey et al. (1986) <BR>Israel 13.29 Belmaker (1982) <BR>Italia 12.2 Zoppi (1992) <BR>Jamaica 13.1 Jamaica National (1988) <BR>Japan 12.5 Nakamura et <BR>Kenya 14.4 Rogo et al. (1987) <BR>Malaysia 14.2 Wilson (1985)<BR>Mexico 12.4 Garcia-Baltazar <BR>Morocco 13.75* Loukid et al. <BR>Nepal (high altitude) 16.2* Beall (1983) <BR>New-Zealand 12.9 St George et <BR>Nicaragua 14.0 Guido et al. <BR>Nigeria 15.0* Morabia et al. <BR>Norway 13.2* Nafstad et al. <BR>Papua New Guinea 15.8 Groos and Smith <BR>Peru 13.23 Soto-Caceres Servigon <BR>Philippines 13.6 Zablan (1988) <BR>Poland 13.06 Laska-Mierzejewska et al. (1982) — — <BR>Romania 13.47 Stukovsky et al. (1967) — — <BR>Russia 13.0 Iampol’skaia (1997) 49.0 Balan (1995) <BR>Sardinia 12.78* Floris et al. (1987) — — <BR>Senegal 16.1 Simondon et al. (1997) — — <BR>Somalia 14.78 Gallo (1975) — — <BR>South Africa (black women) — — 49.2 Walker et al. (1984) <BR>Southern Korea 13.9 Kim et al. (1986) — — <BR>Spain 12.31 de la Puente et al. (1997) — — <BR>Sri Lanka 13.5 Balasuriya and Fernando (1983) — — <BR>Sudan 13.75 Attallah et al. (1983) — — <BR>Sweden 13.09 Furu (1976) 50.9* Hagstad (1988) <BR>Switzerland 13.0 Morabia et al. (1996) 50.0 Morabia et al. (1996) <BR>Tahiti 12.75* Ducros and Ducros (1987) — — <BR>Taiwan 13.6 Chow et al. (1997) 49.5 Chow et al. (1997) <BR>Tanzania 15.21 Hautvast (1971) — — <BR>Thailand 12.3 Piya-Anant et al. (1997) 50.3 Tungphaisal et al. (1991) <BR>Turkey 13.28 Vicdan et al. (1996) 47.8 Carda et al. (1998) <BR>United Arab Emirates — — 47.3 Rizk et al. (1998) <BR>USA 12.8 Malina and Bouchard (1991) 51.3* Kato et al. (1998) <BR>Venezuela 12.68* Farid-Coupal et al. (1981) — — <BR>Yemen 14.4 Yemen Arab Republic Fertility Survey (1979) — — <BR>Zambia 13.7 Katzarski et al. (1980) — — <BR>Zimbabwe 13.5 Mbizvo et al. (1995) — —''"</ref><ref>Also see [http://wikiislam.net/wiki/File:Mean_ages_of_menarche_around_the_world.jpg this] table on the mean ages of menarche around the world (Reference: "[{{Reference archive|1=http://www.mum.org/menarage.htm|2=2013-01-11}} Average age at menarche in various cultures]," The Museum of Menarche (mum.org), accessed January 12, 2013).</ref> В много случаи истината е точно обратната на това, което апологетите казват. Например средната възраст при първа менструация за Дания, Финландия и Великобритания е съответно 13.0, 13.2 и 13.3 години. За сравнение средната възраст при първа менструация за Сенегал, Танзания и Йемен е съответно 16.1, 15.21 и 14.4 години.<ref name="HuBioVol73"></ref>


For girls in the Medieval (5<sup>th</sup> to 15<sup>th</sup> century) Middle East, the average age at menarche was between 12 to 13 years of age, not 9. In fact, the average age at menarche for Medieval Europeans was very similar, at 12 to 14 years of age.<ref name="Mum.org">[{{Reference archive|1=http://www.mum.org/menarage.htm|2=2013-01-11}} Average age at menarche in various cultures] - Mum.org, accessed January 12, 2013</ref>
За момичетата от 5<sup>ти</sup> до 15<sup>ти</sup> век в Средния Изток, средната възраст при менструация е между 12 и 13 години, а не 9. Всъщност, средната възраст на менструация за средновековните европейци е много подобна, на възраст от 12 до 14 години.<ref name="Mum.org">[{{Reference archive|1=http://www.mum.org/menarage.htm|2=2013-01-11}} Average age at menarche in various cultures] - Mum.org, accessed January 12, 2013</ref>


====In 1 hadith Aisha says "When a girl is nine years old, she is a woman (meaning, she has attained puberty)"====
====In 1 hadith Aisha says "When a girl is nine years old, she is a woman (meaning, she has attained puberty)"====
Взето от „http://bg.wikiislam.net/wiki/Специални:MobileDiff/2892“.