УикиИслям

Противоречия в Корана: Разлика между версии

Страница Беседа

Противоречия в Корана (преглед на кода)

Версия от 23:45, 3 декември 2022

96 байта изтрити ,  3 декември 2022
редакция без резюме
[проверена версия][проверена версия]
Редакция без резюме
Редакция без резюме
Ред 1: Ред 1:
<br />
<br />
{{Quote|{{Quran|4|82}}|"Нима не размишляват над Корана? И ако бе от друг, а не от Аллах, щяха да открият в него много противоречия"}}


Тази статия разглежда противоречията в Корана.
Съществува следният стих в Корана:
{{Quote|{{Quran|4|82}}|"'''Нима не размишляват над Корана? И ако бе от друг, а не от Аллах, щяха да открият в него много противоречия'''"}}
<br>


Тази статия разглежда открити противоречия в Корана.<br>




==[[Аллах (определение)|<big>Аллах</big>]]==


 
===Къде е Аллах?===
==[[Аллах (определение)|<big>Аллах</big>]] ==
 
=== Къде е Аллах? ===
На Трон
На Трон
{{Quote|{{Quran|57|4}}|
{{Quote|{{Quran|57|4}}|
Ред 32: Ред 32:
Сътворихме Ние човека и знаем какво му нашепва неговата душа. Ние сме по-близо до него, отколкото вената на шията [му].}}
Сътворихме Ние човека и знаем какво му нашепва неговата душа. Ние сме по-близо до него, отколкото вената на шията [му].}}


=== Аллах ли е единственият застъпник/покровител? ===
===Аллах ли е единственият застъпник/покровител?===
Да
Да
{{Quote|{{Quran|32|4}}|
{{Quote|{{Quran|32|4}}|
Ред 63: Ред 63:
А вярващите мъже и жени са покровители един на друг. Те повеляват одобряваното и възбраняват порицаваното, и отслужват молитвата, и дават милостинята закат, и се покоряват на Аллах и на Неговия Пратеник. Тези Аллах ще помилва. Аллах е всемогъщ, премъдър.}}
А вярващите мъже и жени са покровители един на друг. Те повеляват одобряваното и възбраняват порицаваното, и отслужват молитвата, и дават милостинята закат, и се покоряват на Аллах и на Неговия Пратеник. Тези Аллах ще помилва. Аллах е всемогъщ, премъдър.}}


=== Аллах ли е единственият владетел/водач/покровител без съдружник? ===
===Аллах ли е единственият владетел/водач/покровител без съдружник?===
Да
Да
{{Quote|{{Quran|18|26}}|
{{Quote|{{Quran|18|26}}|
Ред 123: Ред 123:
Всеки пратеник изпращахме само да му се покоряват с позволението на Аллах. И ако те, когато угнетяваха себе си, дойдеха при теб [о, Мухаммад] и помолеха Аллах за опрощение, и Пратеника помолеше за опрощението им, щяха да видят, че Аллах е приемащ покаянието, милосърден.}}
Всеки пратеник изпращахме само да му се покоряват с позволението на Аллах. И ако те, когато угнетяваха себе си, дойдеха при теб [о, Мухаммад] и помолеха Аллах за опрощение, и Пратеника помолеше за опрощението им, щяха да видят, че Аллах е приемащ покаянието, милосърден.}}


=== Can Allah be seen? ===
===Can Allah be seen?===
No
No


Ред 142: Ред 142:
Qur'an 53:1-18
Qur'an 53:1-18


=== Could Allah have a son? ===
===Could Allah have a son?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 159: Ред 159:
Qur'an 6:101
Qur'an 6:101


=== Is it possible to have a son without a consort? ===
===Is it possible to have a son without a consort?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 172: Ред 172:
Qur'an 6:101
Qur'an 6:101


=== Is Allah omniscient? ===
===Is Allah omniscient?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 185: Ред 185:
Qur'an 2:155
Qur'an 2:155


=== Can only Allah see the unseen? ===
===Can only Allah see the unseen?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 198: Ред 198:
Qur'an 27:39
Qur'an 27:39


=== Does Allah lead people astray? ===
===Does Allah lead people astray?===
No
No


Ред 211: Ред 211:
Qur'an 6:25
Qur'an 6:25


=== Is Allah similar to anyone or anything? ===
===Is Allah similar to anyone or anything?===
No
No


Ред 260: Ред 260:
Qur'an 69:17
Qur'an 69:17


=== Is Allah kind and merciful? ===
===Is Allah kind and merciful?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 273: Ред 273:
Qur'an 4:56
Qur'an 4:56


=== Does Allah speak directly with people? ===
===Does Allah speak directly with people?===
No
No


Ред 304: Ред 304:
Qur'an 4:164
Qur'an 4:164


=== Does Allah forgive everything? ===
===Does Allah forgive everything?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 317: Ред 317:
Qur'an 4:116
Qur'an 4:116


=== Does Allah forgive worshipping other gods/shirk? ===
===Does Allah forgive worshipping other gods/shirk?===
No
No


Ред 342: Ред 342:
Qur'an 25:70
Qur'an 25:70


=== How long is Allah's day? ===
===How long is Allah's day?===
One thousand years
One thousand years


Ред 355: Ред 355:
Qur'an 70:4
Qur'an 70:4


== Angels and Demons ==
==Angels and Demons==


=== Can angels walk the earth? ===
===Can angels walk the earth?===
No
No


Ред 376: Ред 376:
Qur'an 15:65
Qur'an 15:65


=== Can angels guard or protect? ===
===Can angels guard or protect?===
No
No


Ред 389: Ред 389:
Qur'an 41:31
Qur'an 41:31


=== How many angels helped Muhammad at Badr? ===
===How many angels helped Muhammad at Badr?===
Three thousand
Three thousand


Ред 408: Ред 408:
Qur'an 15:8
Qur'an 15:8


=== Does Satan mislead devout Muslims? ===
===Does Satan mislead devout Muslims?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 421: Ред 421:
Qur'an 38:83
Qur'an 38:83


=== Was Iblis an Angel or a Jinn? ===
===Was Iblis an Angel or a Jinn?===
Jinn
Jinn


Ред 434: Ред 434:
Qur'an 2:34
Qur'an 2:34


=== Where are the Jinn? ===
===Where are the Jinn?===
On earth and cannot get into space
On earth and cannot get into space


Ред 447: Ред 447:
Qur'an 37:6-7
Qur'an 37:6-7


== Creation ==
==Creation==


=== Which was created first; Universe or Earth? ===
===Which was created first; Universe or Earth?===
Universe
Universe


Ред 472: Ред 472:
Qur'an 2:29
Qur'an 2:29


=== Heaven and Earth came apart or together? ===
===Heaven and Earth came apart or together?===
Together (universe contracting)
Together (universe contracting)


Ред 485: Ред 485:
Qur'an 21:30
Qur'an 21:30


=== How long did it take Allah to create heaven and earth? ===
===How long did it take Allah to create heaven and earth?===
6 days
6 days


Ред 500: Ред 500:
Qur'an 41:9-12
Qur'an 41:9-12


=== What was Man created from? ===
===What was Man created from?===
Dust
Dust


Ред 537: Ред 537:
Qur'an 21:30
Qur'an 21:30


=== How long does it take Allah to create? ===
===How long does it take Allah to create?===
Long time
Long time


Ред 550: Ред 550:
Qur'an 2:117
Qur'an 2:117


== Day of Judgement ==
==Day of Judgement==


=== How many trumpets will be blown on Qiyamah? ===
===How many trumpets will be blown on Qiyamah?===
Two
Two


Ред 565: Ред 565:
Qur'an 69:13
Qur'an 69:13


=== What happens to mountains on Qiyamah? ===
===What happens to mountains on Qiyamah?===
Become like wool
Become like wool


Ред 578: Ред 578:
Qur'an 78:20
Qur'an 78:20


=== Will disbelievers speak on Qiyamah? ===
===Will disbelievers speak on Qiyamah?===
No
No


Ред 591: Ред 591:
Qur'an 36:65
Qur'an 36:65


=== Where do disbelievers receive their record book on Judgment day? ===
===Where do disbelievers receive their record book on Judgment day?===
On their back
On their back


Ред 604: Ред 604:
Qur'an 69:25
Qur'an 69:25


== Evil ==
==Evil==


=== Does evil come from Allah? ===
===Does evil come from Allah?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 619: Ред 619:
Qur'an 4:79
Qur'an 4:79


=== Does Allah command evil or not? ===
===Does Allah command evil or not?===
The Qur'an in the following verses says Allah will not command indecency or evil
The Qur'an in the following verses says Allah will not command indecency or evil


Ред 640: Ред 640:
Qur'an 17:16
Qur'an 17:16


=== Magic ===
===Magic===
Moses instructed by Allah to do magic
Moses instructed by Allah to do magic


Ред 653: Ред 653:
Qur'an 113:4
Qur'an 113:4


=== Are animals evil? ===
===Are animals evil?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 672: Ред 672:
Qur'an 22:18
Qur'an 22:18


== Heaven and Hell ==
==Heaven and Hell==


=== When do people come back to life? ===
===When do people come back to life?===
On the appointed Hour (Day of Judgement)
On the appointed Hour (Day of Judgement)


Ред 687: Ред 687:
Qur'an 3:169
Qur'an 3:169


=== Is there heaven and hell only? ===
===Is there heaven and hell only?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 700: Ред 700:
Qur'an 7:46
Qur'an 7:46


=== Is intercession possible? ===
===Is intercession possible?===
No
No


Ред 725: Ред 725:
Qur'an 10:3
Qur'an 10:3


=== Width of garden; 1 heaven or plural heavens? ===
===Width of garden; 1 heaven or plural heavens?===
More than one heaven (plural, samawaat)
More than one heaven (plural, samawaat)


Ред 738: Ред 738:
Qur'an 57:21
Qur'an 57:21


=== Who will men be with in paradise? ===
===Who will men be with in paradise?===
With their wives from Earth
With their wives from Earth


Ред 751: Ред 751:
Qur'an 52:20
Qur'an 52:20


=== Do all Muslims go to hell for some time? ===
===Do all Muslims go to hell for some time?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 772: Ред 772:
Qur'an 47:12
Qur'an 47:12


=== Will non-Muslims go to hell forever? ===
===Will non-Muslims go to hell forever?===
Not necessarily
Not necessarily


Ред 803: Ред 803:
Qur'an 41:28
Qur'an 41:28


=== Will Jesus burn in Hell? ===
===Will Jesus burn in Hell?===
Yes, because he is worshipped as God by Christians
Yes, because he is worshipped as God by Christians


Ред 816: Ред 816:
Qur'an 3:45
Qur'an 3:45


=== What will be the food in hell? ===
===What will be the food in hell?===
Only thorns/ dhari
Only thorns/ dhari


Ред 835: Ред 835:
Qur'an 37:66
Qur'an 37:66


== Mankind ==
==Mankind==


=== What is the purpose of mankind? ===
===What is the purpose of mankind?===
Only to worship Allah
Only to worship Allah


Ред 850: Ред 850:
Qur'an 7:158
Qur'an 7:158


=== Are all human races considered equal? ===
===Are all human races considered equal?===
No
No


Ред 869: Ред 869:
Qur'an 49:13
Qur'an 49:13


=== Does everyone bear his own burden? ===
===Does everyone bear his own burden?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 912: Ред 912:
Qur'an 29:13
Qur'an 29:13


=== Does Man have free will? ===
===Does Man have free will?===
No
No


Ред 925: Ред 925:
Qur'an 81:28
Qur'an 81:28


=== When was our fate written? ===
===When was our fate written?===
Before Allah created the heavens and the Earth
Before Allah created the heavens and the Earth


Ред 938: Ред 938:
Qur'an 44:3
Qur'an 44:3


=== Who takes peoples souls? ===
===Who takes peoples souls?===
One angel
One angel


Ред 957: Ред 957:
Qur'an 39:42
Qur'an 39:42


== Muslims ==
==Muslims==


=== Who was the first Muslim? ===
===Who was the first Muslim?===
Muhammed
Muhammed


Ред 1012: Ред 1012:
Qur'an 5:111
Qur'an 5:111


=== Is Allah the only Wali? ===
===Is Allah the only Wali?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1025: Ред 1025:
Qur'an 5:55
Qur'an 5:55


=== Does a Muslim have only one mother? ===
===Does a Muslim have only one mother?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1044: Ред 1044:
Qur'an 33:6
Qur'an 33:6


=== Strength of believers ===
===Strength of believers===
One Muslim is more powerful than 10 non-Muslims
One Muslim is more powerful than 10 non-Muslims


Ред 1057: Ред 1057:
Qur'an 8:66
Qur'an 8:66


=== Can you eat non-halal meat? ===
===Can you eat non-halal meat?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1070: Ред 1070:
Qur'an 6:118
Qur'an 6:118


=== Is jewellery okay? ===
===Is jewellery okay?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1087: Ред 1087:
Qur'an 28:76
Qur'an 28:76


=== Is an adopted child real family? ===
===Is an adopted child real family?===
No
No


Ред 1102: Ред 1102:
Qur'an 4:23
Qur'an 4:23


=== Is drinking alcohol okay? ===
===Is drinking alcohol okay?===
Yes, we will drink Alcohol with Allah for an eternity
Yes, we will drink Alcohol with Allah for an eternity


Ред 1145: Ред 1145:
Qur'an 5:90
Qur'an 5:90


=== How many sacred months are there? ===
===How many sacred months are there?===
Four
Four


Ред 1158: Ред 1158:
Qur'an 5:2
Qur'an 5:2


== Non-Muslims ==
==Non-Muslims==


=== What does Allah do with apostates? ===
===What does Allah do with apostates?===
Punishes them
Punishes them


Ред 1173: Ред 1173:
Qur'an 60:6
Qur'an 60:6


=== Is there compulsion in Islam? ===
===Is there compulsion in Islam?===
No
No


Ред 1198: Ред 1198:
Qur'an 9:29
Qur'an 9:29


=== Will Allah reward the good deeds of non-Muslims? ===
===Will Allah reward the good deeds of non-Muslims?===
No
No


Ред 1211: Ред 1211:
Qur'an 99:7
Qur'an 99:7


=== Who sends disbelievers astray? ===
===Who sends disbelievers astray?===
Allah
Allah


Ред 1266: Ред 1266:
Qur'an 30:9
Qur'an 30:9


=== For whom is salvation? ===
===For whom is salvation?===
For all pious theists
For all pious theists


Ред 1291: Ред 1291:
Qur'an 3:19
Qur'an 3:19


=== How to treat those who do not believe in an afterlife ===
===How to treat those who do not believe in an afterlife===
Be kind
Be kind


Ред 1310: Ред 1310:
Qur'an 9:29
Qur'an 9:29


=== What to do with infidel family? ===
===What to do with infidel family?===
Stay with family
Stay with family


Ред 1323: Ред 1323:
Qur'an 9:23
Qur'an 9:23


== People of the Book ==
==People of the Book==


=== Should Muslims have Christians for friends? ===
===Should Muslims have Christians for friends?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1344: Ред 1344:
Qur'an 5:51
Qur'an 5:51


=== Christians and Jews hate or love each other? ===
===Christians and Jews hate or love each other?===
Hate each other
Hate each other


Ред 1357: Ред 1357:
Qur'an 5:51
Qur'an 5:51


=== Can you marry non-Muslims? ===
===Can you marry non-Muslims?===
No
No


Ред 1370: Ред 1370:
Qur'an 5:5
Qur'an 5:5


=== Do Muslims and non-Muslim theists worship the same god? ===
===Do Muslims and non-Muslim theists worship the same god?===
No
No


Ред 1383: Ред 1383:
Qur'an 29:46
Qur'an 29:46


=== Will Jews and Christians be saved from hell? ===
===Will Jews and Christians be saved from hell?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1408: Ред 1408:
Qur'an 3:85
Qur'an 3:85


== Prophets ==
==Prophets==


=== Who does Allah send as prophets? ===
===Who does Allah send as prophets?===
Only single men from amongst a community
Only single men from amongst a community


Ред 1441: Ред 1441:
Qur'an 99:2
Qur'an 99:2


=== Are all Islamic prophets equal? ===
===Are all Islamic prophets equal?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1454: Ред 1454:
Qur'an 2:253
Qur'an 2:253


=== Will Muhammad go to Heaven? ===
===Will Muhammad go to Heaven?===
Yes, he will be forgiven of all sins
Yes, he will be forgiven of all sins


Ред 1467: Ред 1467:
Qur'an 46:9
Qur'an 46:9


=== How did Abraham confront the idolaters? ===
===How did Abraham confront the idolaters?===
Destroys idols
Destroys idols


Ред 1480: Ред 1480:
Qur'an 19:49
Qur'an 19:49


=== Can messengers perform miracles? ===
===Can messengers perform miracles?===
No
No


Ред 1493: Ред 1493:
Qur'an 2:253
Qur'an 2:253


=== Are all messengers descended from Abraham? ===
===Are all messengers descended from Abraham?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1508: Ред 1508:
Qur'an 16:36
Qur'an 16:36


=== Was Abraham an idolator? ===
===Was Abraham an idolator?===
No
No


Ред 1521: Ред 1521:
Qur'an 6:76
Qur'an 6:76


=== Was Noah banished or exiled by his people? ===
===Was Noah banished or exiled by his people?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1534: Ред 1534:
Qur'an 6:101
Qur'an 6:101


=== Did Noah's son survive the great flood? ===
===Did Noah's son survive the great flood?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1553: Ред 1553:
Qur'an 11:43
Qur'an 11:43


=== Was Jonah cast on the shore? ===
===Was Jonah cast on the shore?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1566: Ред 1566:
Qur'an 68:49
Qur'an 68:49


== Sex ==
==Sex==


=== Is adultery permitted? ===
===Is adultery permitted?===
Here Allah tells unmarried Muslims they can't fornicate
Here Allah tells unmarried Muslims they can't fornicate


Ред 1587: Ред 1587:
Qur'an 23:6
Qur'an 23:6


=== Can you commit incest? ===
===Can you commit incest?===
There's a double standard with Allah allowing the children of Adam to reproduce but disallowing it for later generations.
There's a double standard with Allah allowing the children of Adam to reproduce but disallowing it for later generations.


Ред 1602: Ред 1602:
Qur'an 7:172
Qur'an 7:172


=== Is polygamy okay? ===
===Is polygamy okay?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1615: Ред 1615:
Qur'an 4:129
Qur'an 4:129


== Women ==
==Women==


=== Are men and women equal? ===
===Are men and women equal?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1636: Ред 1636:
Qur'an 2:228
Qur'an 2:228


=== Can slander of chaste women be forgiven? ===
===Can slander of chaste women be forgiven?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1649: Ред 1649:
Qur'an 24:23
Qur'an 24:23


== Qur'an ==
==Qur'an==


=== Who brought the revelation to Muhammad? ===
===Who brought the revelation to Muhammad?===
Holy spirit
Holy spirit


Ред 1664: Ред 1664:
Qur'an 2:97
Qur'an 2:97


=== Who is the intended audience of the revelation? ===
===Who is the intended audience of the revelation?===
Arabs
Arabs


Ред 1683: Ред 1683:
Qur'an 62:2
Qur'an 62:2


=== How was the Qur'an revealed? ===
===How was the Qur'an revealed?===
Night
Night


Ред 1708: Ред 1708:
Qur'an 25:32
Qur'an 25:32


=== Clarity of the Qur'an? ===
===Clarity of the Qur'an?===
Qur'an is clear to understand
Qur'an is clear to understand


Ред 1727: Ред 1727:
Qur'an 2:1
Qur'an 2:1


=== Is the Qur'an in pure Arabic? ===
===Is the Qur'an in pure Arabic?===
Yes
Yes


Ред 1746: Ред 1746:
Qur'an 15:74
Qur'an 15:74


=== Abrogation; does Allah change his words? ===
===Abrogation; does Allah change his words?===
No
No


Ред 1771: Ред 1771:
Qur'an 16:101
Qur'an 16:101


== Miscellaneous ==
==Miscellaneous==


=== When did Pharaoh command killing of baby boys? ===
===When did Pharaoh command killing of baby boys?===
When moses was a prophet
When moses was a prophet


Ред 1786: Ред 1786:
Qur'an 20:39
Qur'an 20:39


=== How many Thamud killed the she-camel? ===
===How many Thamud killed the she-camel?===
One
One


Ред 1799: Ред 1799:
Qur'an 7:77
Qur'an 7:77


=== Did Pagan Meccans get revelation before Muhammad? ===
===Did Pagan Meccans get revelation before Muhammad?===
No
No


Ред 1812: Ред 1812:
Qur'an 10:47
Qur'an 10:47


=== Was the Pharaoh killed? ===
===Was the Pharaoh killed?===
No
No


Ред 1841: Ред 1841:
Qur'an 17:103
Qur'an 17:103


=== How long did it take to destroy Aad tribe? ===
===How long did it take to destroy Aad tribe?===
One day
One day


Ред 1860: Ред 1860:
Qur'an 69:7
Qur'an 69:7


=== How many gods are there? ===
===How many gods are there?===
One
One


Ред 1891: Ред 1891:
Qur'an 53:19
Qur'an 53:19


=== How long to wean? ===
===How long to wean?===
30 months
30 months


Ред 1904: Ред 1904:
Qur'an 31:14
Qur'an 31:14


=== How many cardinal points does Allah have? ===
===How many cardinal points does Allah have?===
Single
Single


Ред 1925: Ред 1925:
''This page is featured in the core article, '''Islam and Scripture''' which serves as a starting point for anyone wishing to learn more about this topic''  
''This page is featured in the core article, '''Islam and Scripture''' which serves as a starting point for anyone wishing to learn more about this topic''  


== See Also ==
==See Also==
 
*Contradictions and Errors ''- A hub page that leads to other articles related to Contradictions and Errors''
*Contradictions in the Qur'an (Response)
 
==External links==
 
*Contradictions in the Qur'an ''- More contradictions in the Qur'an, Answering Islam''
*1000 MISTAKES.com ''- Website dedicated to exposing mistakes in the Qur'an''
*A Guide To Quranic Contradictions ''- By Abul Kasem, April 20, 2008''
*The Last Verse of the Quran That It Was Not ''- Mumin Salih, Islam Watch, September 27, 2009''


* Contradictions and Errors ''- A hub page that leads to other articles related to Contradictions and Errors''
* Contradictions in the Qur'an (Response)


== External links ==


* Contradictions in the Qur'an ''- More contradictions in the Qur'an, Answering Islam''
[[Category:Не завършени статии]]
* 1000 MISTAKES.com ''- Website dedicated to exposing mistakes in the Qur'an''
* A Guide To Quranic Contradictions ''- By Abul Kasem, April 20, 2008''
* The Last Verse of the Quran That It Was Not ''- Mumin Salih, Islam Watch, September 27, 2009''
Взето от „http://bg.wikiislam.net/wiki/Специални:MobileDiff/4898“.