Отговори на защитниците: Мухаммад и Аиша: Разлика между версии

[проверена версия][проверена версия]
Ред 102: Ред 102:
Дори днес не е необичайно за членовете на някакъв култ да предоставят малките си деца на своя лидер с цел ''брак'' и сексуални злоупотреби.<ref>"''He [Albert Tony Walker] began showing affection to married women, and grooming the group’s younger women to be his “spiritual brides.” He convinced Silva that allowing him to bed her daughters was the right thing to do, talking to her for hours about saving them from “some worldly guy,” she recalled. “He said, ‘God had given us the power to bring on the seed of God, and how great would that be to have your children blessed?’ ” Kalena is a grown woman and mother of two now with honey-brown hair cascading down to her waist. Her clear blue eyes grow tearful when she remembers how Walker began separating her from her mother and siblings at age 11 to fondle her. At 12, he began raping her, telling her he wanted her to bear his child. Eventually, at 16, she did get pregnant.''" - [{{Reference archive|1=http://www.ajc.com/news/family-members-who-lost-854282.html|2=2011-10-24}} Family members who lost faith find justice] - Andria Simmons, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, February 27, 2011</ref> Ето защо дори и ако тя беше предложена на Мухаммад, това не би оправдало брака по никакъв начин.
Дори днес не е необичайно за членовете на някакъв култ да предоставят малките си деца на своя лидер с цел ''брак'' и сексуални злоупотреби.<ref>"''He [Albert Tony Walker] began showing affection to married women, and grooming the group’s younger women to be his “spiritual brides.” He convinced Silva that allowing him to bed her daughters was the right thing to do, talking to her for hours about saving them from “some worldly guy,” she recalled. “He said, ‘God had given us the power to bring on the seed of God, and how great would that be to have your children blessed?’ ” Kalena is a grown woman and mother of two now with honey-brown hair cascading down to her waist. Her clear blue eyes grow tearful when she remembers how Walker began separating her from her mother and siblings at age 11 to fondle her. At 12, he began raping her, telling her he wanted her to bear his child. Eventually, at 16, she did get pregnant.''" - [{{Reference archive|1=http://www.ajc.com/news/family-members-who-lost-854282.html|2=2011-10-24}} Family members who lost faith find justice] - Andria Simmons, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, February 27, 2011</ref> Ето защо дори и ако тя беше предложена на Мухаммад, това не би оправдало брака по никакъв начин.


====Abu Bakr became the 1st Caliph. Muhammad married Aisha to "cement the relations of the budding nation"====
====Абу Бакр е бил Първият Халиф. Мухаммад се е оженил за Аиша, за да „циментира отношенията в зараждащата се нация“====


Abu Bakr was already Muhammad's closest companion. There was no need for him to "cement relations" with Abu Bakr by marrying his 6-year-old daughter, and thereby forever legitimizing child-marriages within Islam.  
Абу Бакр вече бил най-близкият сподвижник на Миухаммад. Нямало е нужда Мухаммад да „циментира отношенията“ с Абу Бакр, като се жени за неговата 6-годишна дъщеря, с което завинаги да легитимира браковете с деца в исляма.  


Additionally, if this was the sole purpose behind the marriage, he could have just as easily married Abu Bakr's other daughter, Asma bint Abu Bakr, who was a lot older and not married at the time.
Освен това, ако това е била единствената причина за този брак, той просто е можел да се ожени за другата дъщеря на Абу Бакр – Асма бинт Абу Бакр, която е била доста по-голяма и все още неомъжена по онова време.


====Aisha consented to the marriage. If it was abuse, she would have left Muhammad====
====Aisha consented to the marriage. If it was abuse, she would have left Muhammad====